vSide
First impressions: Seeing the word "party" on the main page did not seem like a promising start, at least for my educational purposes. Once again, we find a site that is free to join, but has premium add-ons available for purchase.
Age range: Intended for ages 13 and up.
Pros: I found it quite challenging to find any positive aspects to this site, other than the fact that it clearly meets teens where they are.
Cons: The environments have many bars and clubs, not the ideal situation to put young students in. Overall it seems very shallow; based on appearance, partying, and consumerism. This consumerism is further perpetuated by the abundance of ads peppering the site.
Overall rating: 2 out of 10
Blue Mars
First impressions: Blue Mars has some aspects of vSide with its avatar-based world and chat, but seems to run a bit deeper. The site seems fairly small, and not very current - the copyright dates the last update as 2010.
Age range: Blue Mars appears to be targeted at adults.
Pros: Seems similar to Second Life in its customisability of "cities," not unlike islands. I find the fact that it is set in the future on a different planet particularly intriguing.
Cons: The lack of currency is a bit of a concern. In addition, since I primarily work with younger students, an adult environment does not seem like the best fit for my purposes.
Overall rating: 4 out of 10
First impressions: Twinity's main page shows pictures of hot tubs, cocktails, and parties. Once again, I'm not sure if that's the sort of environment I want to be bringing students into for educational purposes.
Age range: It is not explicitly stated, but I would guess ages 13 and up.
Pros: My understanding is that in Twinity, they are recreating major world cities for users to explore, which seems like an exciting and fun feature for teachers and students. There is also a big emphasis on user-generated content.
Cons: On the whole, it seems to be fairly average for a site of this kind - nothing all that new or unique that other platforms are not doing.
Overall rating: 6 out of 10
Reflections
Yesterday remains my strongest day for sites that I can see a viable use for. I think with many of these sites, I would really need to go in and see for myself what else they have to offer beyond avatars and customisable spaces.
**********
Currently reading: same!
Current high: chatting with my sweet G5 girls on duty this morning
Current low: the sheer exhaustion that hits on a Friday night after a full week of work
No comments:
Post a Comment